Ars Technica's review of Mike Flanagan's Carrie describes the re-imagining as a triumphant remix and says it is well worth watching. The review focuses on how Flanagan updates Stephen King's classic while staying connected to the familiar story and characters.
However, the review also identifies one major flaw that keeps the project from being fully successful. It does not argue that the flaw sinks the film, but it is significant enough to matter for viewers deciding whether to watch.
Because this article relies on a single source, there is no independent critical agreement or disagreement to compare. The takeaway from Ars Technica is clear: Carrie is a strong remix, but not an unqualified one.