Both reviews agree that the Mac Studio with M5 Ultra is a compact powerhouse for AI and graphics. Tom's Hardware calls it a "local model citizen" that outpaces Nvidia's DGX Spark and AMD's Threadripper in AI tasks, while Engadget acknowledges the huge AI and graphics power packed into the small chassis.
Where they differ is value. Engadget emphasizes the "huge premium," noting that at $11,299, the M5 Ultra's extra performance over the M5 Max model is only worth it for select buyers. Tom's Hardware is more enthusiastic, framing the machine as a productivity and AI win that justifies its place in a small desktop.
The disagreement is not about performance but about audience. Both outlets see the M5 Ultra as technically impressive, but Engadget's caution about the price stands in contrast to Tom's Hardware's focus on the performance lead over dedicated AI hardware.