Large language models are increasingly used to generate differential diagnoses, but a second opinion in a clinical setting must be more than just plausible. According to a new arXiv preprint, it must also be factually grounded, clinically coherent, actionable, and safe. The authors introduce AI Consilium, a multidimensional benchmark designed to evaluate these qualities.

The abstract does not provide specifics about the benchmark's construction or results, but the framing suggests a shift from simple accuracy to a broader set of clinical requirements. The benchmark likely tests models on multiple dimensions, though the details are not yet public.

This work highlights the gap between generating a list of possible conditions and providing a genuinely useful second opinion. As LLMs enter clinical workflows, benchmarks like this could help measure whether they meet the standard of care.