Researchers tested a 2.3 kg six-legged robot, SandBot, running on a bed of 1 mm poppy seeds to study how granular media affect legged locomotion. On hard ground the robot reached about 2 body lengths per second, or roughly 60 cm/s. With standard gait control parameters on the granular bed, however, speeds were at best two orders of magnitude slower, showing that settings tuned for rigid surfaces do not transfer to flowing ground.

By empirically adjusting the control parameters away from the hard-ground settings, the team restored good performance, achieving top speeds of 30 cm/s. The robot's speed depended sensitively on the packing fraction of the granular material and the limb frequency. When the packing fraction became small enough or the limb frequency large enough, the robot underwent a dramatic transition from rotary walking to a slow swimming mode.

The authors proposed a kinematic model of the rotary walking mode based on generic features of penetration and slip of a curved limb in granular media. The model reproduced the dependence of speed on limb frequency and the walking-to-swimming transition, but the authors note that a deeper understanding of granular physics is still needed. Since this is a single source, there are no conflicting findings to compare.