Engadget's review of the Turtle Beach Rematch Wireless Controller for Switch 2 awards it an 8/10, highlighting its adorable licensed designs and RGB lighting as the standout selling point. The controller comes in multiple themed variants—such as Rosalina, KK Slider, and Mario Kart World—all at the same price, which could help Turtle Beach carve out a niche among Switch 2 owners who value aesthetics as much as performance.

The Rematch features TMR thumbsticks that are precise and drift-free, a capability the official Nintendo Switch 2 Pro Controller doesn't offer. It also includes motion controls, a GameChat button, and a 40-hour battery life (12 hours with RGB on). However, it lacks haptic feedback and cannot wake the console, and the reviewer notes a hollow feel that might read as cheap to some users.

For a business audience, the review suggests Turtle Beach is betting on emotional appeal—whimsy and character-driven design—to differentiate in a crowded accessory market. The trade-offs are clear, but the reviewer found the controller comfortable and responsive, especially for smaller hands, and praised its low-latency wireless performance. Whether that charm outweighs the missing premium features remains a consumer choice, but the positive rating indicates a viable product for the company.